Every other week we play one of the top games in the roguelike pantheon then rank em. If you’re interested in our raw source data that we use to guide the podcast, you can find that here.

Two major rules that we abide by are:

  1. it’s okay to like or not like a game
  2. all devs go to heaven

The full combined ranking data can be found below:

(Special thanks to tabletomarkdown.com)

Overall Rank Game Scott rank Colin rank Will rank Andrew rank Avg rank Median rank Std Dev
1 FTL: Faster Than Light 3 1 5 3 3.00 3 1.63
2 Monster Train 6 2 3 5 4.00 4 1.83
3 Binding of Isaac: Rebirth 5 11 5 4 6.25 5 3.20
4 Hand of Fate 2 9 6 5 6 6.50 6 1.73
5 The Last Spell 10 4 14 2 7.50 7 5.51
6 Cogmind 1 3 21 7 8.00 5 9.02
7 Loop Hero 12 8 5 8 8.25 8 2.87
8 Invisible, Inc. 19 5 3 9 9.00 7 7.12
9 Fights in Tight Spaces 15 7 5 10 9.25 9 4.35
10 One Way Heroics 7 17 9 5 9.50 8 5.26
11 Enter the Gungeon 4 20 14 1 9.75 9 8.81
12 Risk of Rain 2 9 17 11 9.75 10 6.18
13 Luck Be A Landlord 16 15 1 12 11.00 14 6.88
14 Griftlands 8 13 11 13 11.25 12 2.36
15 Streets of Rogue 13 12 11 14 12.50 13 1.29
16 Cult of the Lamb 17 10 10 15 13.00 13 3.56
17 Warsim: The Realm of Aslona 14 24 2 16 14.00 15 9.09
18 Stacklands 18 21 11 17 16.75 18 4.19
19 Shattered Pixel Dungeon 20 14 21 19 18.50 20 3.11
20 Hand of Fate 22 19 16 18 18.75 19 2.50
21 Darkest Dungeon 2 11 28 21 20 20.00 21 6.98
22 Dungeons of Dredmor 23 23 17 21 21.00 22 2.83
24 Din’s Curse 28 18 21 22 22.25 22 4.19
23 Brotato 21 16 21 32 22.50 21 6.76
25 Pineapple Smash Crew 25 22 27 23 24.25 24 2.22
26 Eldritch 26 26 17 31 25.00 26 5.83
27 Sword of the Stars: The Pit 27 29 21 24 25.25 26 3.50
28 Cataclysm: Dark Days Ahead 32 25 17 33 26.75 29 7.41
29 Cargo Commander 24 32 29 26 27.75 28 3.50
30 Low Magic Age 29 30 27 25 27.75 28 2.22
31 A Valley Without Wind 31 27 32 27 29.25 29 2.63
32 Hack, Slash, Loot 30 33 29 28 30.00 30 2.16
33 Realm of the Mad God 33 31 31 29 31.00 31 1.63