Every other week we play one of the top games in the roguelike pantheon then rank em. If you’re interested in our raw source data that we use to guide the podcast, you can find that here.

Two major rules that we abide by are: 1) it’s okay to like or not like a game, and 2) all devs go to heaven.

The full combined ranking data can be found below:

(Special thanks to tabletomarkdown.com)

Overall Rank Game Scott rank Colin rank Will rank Avg rank Median rank Std Dev
1 FTL: Faster Than Light 3 1 4 2.67 3.00 1.53
2 Monster Train 5 3 2 3.33 3.00 1.53
3 Hand of Fate 2 7 5 4 5.33 5.00 1.53
4 Binding of Isaac: Rebirth 4 9 4 5.67 4.00 2.89
5 Cogmind 1 2 15 6.00 2.00 7.81
6 Invisible, Inc. 13 4 2 6.33 4.00 5.86
7 Loop Hero 8 7 4 6.33 7.00 2.08
8 Fights in Tight Spaces 11 6 4 7.00 6.00 3.61
9 Risk of Rain 2 8 13 7.67 8.00 5.51
10 Griftlands 6 11 9 8.67 9.00 2.52
11 Streets of Rogue 9 10 9 9.33 9.00 0.58
12 Warsim: The Realm of Aslona 10 17 1 9.33 10.00 8.02
13 Stacklands 12 14 9 11.67 12.00 2.52
14 Hand of Fate 14 13 12 13.00 13.00 1.00
15 Dungeons of Dredmor 15 16 13 14.67 15.00 1.53
16 Din’s Curse 19 12 15 15.33 15.00 3.51
17 Pineapple Smash Crew 17 15 18 16.67 17.00 1.53
18 Sword of the Stars: The Pit 18 19 15 17.33 18.00 2.08
19 Low Magic Age 20 20 18 19.33 20.00 1.15
20 Cargo Commander 16 22 20 19.33 20.00 3.06
21 A Valley Without Wind 22 18 23 21.00 22.00 2.65
22 Hack, Slash, Loot 21 23 20 21.33 21.00 1.53
23 Realm of the Mad God 23 21 22 22.00 22.00 1.00